Skip to content

Can’t Afford a Court Reporter? California Guarantees a Court Record

 

Almost every week, I talk with someone who has a court hearing coming up and no court reporter. A court reporter is the trained professional who takes down every word said in the courtroom. These callers find SoniClear while searching for any way to record their hearing. The referral lists they've been given point to transcriptionists or outdated companies. Sometimes we can connect them with one of our court reporters. But their question is always the same: how do I make sure there is a record of what happens?

On August 10, 2026, the California Supreme Court gave a clearer answer. In a unanimous decision in Family Violence Appellate Project v. Superior Court, the court said that if no court reporter is available and you can't afford to hire one, you can ask the court to record your hearing.

The court pointed to rules California already has for how this works. The hearing is recorded on approved equipment. A person the court chooses, often a clerk, runs the recording and keeps notes on who is speaking and what is happening. At the end of the day, that person signs a certificate confirming the equipment worked and the hearing was captured. If you need a transcript for an appeal, a clerk or a professional transcription service types up the recording word for word and signs a sworn statement that it is accurate. Under California Rules of Court, rule 2.952, the law presumes that certified transcript is a true and complete record of what was said. That means it counts on appeal just like a court reporter's transcript. A recording on your own phone does not. Even if a judge lets you make one, it can serve only as your personal notes.

The ruling turns a promise California made in 2018 into a guarantee courts must keep.

Why Does a Court Record Matter?

If you lose a case and believe the judge got it wrong, you can ask a higher court to review the decision. This is called an appeal. The higher court does not hold a new hearing. It reads the written record of what was said, called a transcript, and decides whether a mistake was made.

The person appealing has to show the mistake using that record. Without a transcript, there is often nothing to show, and the appeal can fail before it starts. That is why a word for word record, which courts call a verbatim record, matters so much.

How Many Hearings Have Gone Unrecorded?

California does not have enough court reporters, and the gap is large. Since April 1, 2023, more than three million hearings in larger civil lawsuits, family law, and probate cases (estates, conservatorships, and guardianships) have gone forward with no verbatim record, according to the Judicial Branch of California. That is about 71 percent of the 4.2 million such hearings held through March 2026.

The court's opinion cites the California Access to Justice Commission, which found that in the year ending March 31, 2024, over one million hearings and trials in these case types had no way to create an official transcript. In more than 70 percent of those proceedings, the people involved had no access to one.

Local numbers tell the same story. Los Angeles Superior Court held more than 332,000 hearings without a verbatim record in 2023. Santa Clara held more than 56,000 that year, and by late 2024 was averaging nearly 290 such hearings every day.

These are not minor matters. They include domestic violence and civil harassment restraining orders, child custody and support, divorce, debt collection, housing and employment discrimination, and conservatorships and guardianships.

The reason is simple: there are not enough reporters. The Judicial Council, which sets policy for California courts, estimates the courts need at least 458 more full time court reporters. Courts have raised pay and offered signing bonuses and tuition support. Hiring has improved, but not fast enough to close the gap. For people in court, the alternative is expensive: CalMatters reports that hiring a private reporter can cost more than $3,000 per hearing.

What Did the California Supreme Court Decide?

In 2018, in Jameson v. Desta, the California Supreme Court ruled that trial courts must provide an official court reporter, at no cost, to people who cannot afford one and ask for it. Eight years later, in the August 2026 opinion she wrote for a unanimous court, Chief Justice Patricia Guerrero acknowledged that because many California courts do not employ enough reporters, "this guarantee has proven illusory."

The 2026 decision closes that gap. When someone who cannot afford a private reporter asks for an official verbatim record, the court must provide a way to get one. This applies in every type of case. If no official court reporter is available, the court must record the hearing electronically.

These parts of the ruling matter most for people going to court:

  • More people qualify. You don't need a fee waiver or a formal application. If you can't reasonably afford a private reporter, you can ask the court for a record.
  • It covers every kind of case. Some courts had offered recording only in the most serious matters, those involving fundamental rights or personal liberty. The court said that falls short. The duty applies in all cases.
  • Recording is proven elsewhere. The court noted that federal courts and other states already rely on electronic recording, and that California Rules of Court 2.952 and 2.954 set standards for the equipment and how it is operated. In the Chief Justice's words, "a verbatim record created by electronic recording is better than no record at all."
  • The reporter is the first choice. A state law, Government Code section 69957, bars electronic recording in most cases. The ruling allows recording only when no official reporter is available. If the court has a reporter, the reporter makes the record.
  • The law still stands. The court did not strike down section 69957. It read the law as including an exception for people who cannot afford a private reporter, and it left bigger constitutional questions for another day.
  • The policy debate continues. Bills to expand recording have stalled in Sacramento in recent sessions, and the Legislature could still revisit the law.
  • Training rooted in court reporting. IDCR brings decades of stenographic court reporting experience to digital court reporter training, carrying the standards of the profession into every recorded courtroom.
  • A career path for courtroom staff. Many courts already have the right people in the room. A courtroom clerk who knows the calendar, the judge, and the flow of a hearing is well placed to become a certified digital court reporter. California's rules already allow a court to choose the person who operates its recording equipment. IDCR training gives that person the skills and credentials to do it well, through live online classes with experienced teachers or study at their own pace. For the court, that means trained staff are ready when a reporter isn't available. For the clerk, it is a meaningful step up in skills and responsibility.
  • A record built for transcripts. Multichannel audio and video, live transcription on screen, speaker names entered during the hearing, and a rough draft created in real time all speed up review and final certification of the transcript.

The court's order applies directly to the four superior courts named in the case: Los Angeles, Santa Clara, Contra Costa, and San Diego. But the duty it describes comes from a power every California trial court has: the power to make sure people with limited means can get fair access to justice. Courts across the state are now working out what the ruling requires of them, and the Judicial Council has formed a working group to study it.

Do Court Reporters Still Come First?

Yes. Court reporters remain the standard for the official record. The ruling makes sure people aren't left with nothing when a reporter is unavailable.

The court also declined to assign blame for the shortage. Court reporter organizations argued that better hiring would help, and their attorney said the ruling should increase job opportunities for reporters. Courts point to a shrinking workforce: nearly half of active California court reporter licenses were issued at least 30 years ago, and only 8 recognized court reporting programs remain open, down from 17 in 2010. Both views can be true. A complete record for every person in court will take skilled reporters and well-run recordings, working side by side.

What Makes Courtroom Recording Work Well?

A recording is only as good as the way it is made. In our work with courts, a few practices consistently make the difference:

  1. Clear standards. California Rules of Court 2.952 and 2.954 already describe requirements for recording equipment and how it is run. That gives courts a ready foundation for their own procedures.
  2. Every voice captured. Each microphone recorded on its own track, microphones placed close to each speaker, and notes linked to the exact moment in the recording all make transcripts more accurate and faster to produce. SoniClear Court Recorder 10 records up to 12 microphone channels separately and links each note to its exact moment in the audio.
  3. Someone listening in real time. Trained staff who watch audio levels and flag moments that are hard to hear can fix problems before the hearing ends.
  4. A clear process for transcripts. Courts that decide early how people request transcripts, who prepares and certifies them, and how quickly they are delivered avoid delays later.
  5. Quality checks. Measuring recording quality and turnaround times gives a court clear evidence that its record is reliable.

How Does SoniClear Support Courts?

The ruling is clear on priorities: when a court reporter is available, the reporter makes the record. Recording steps in only when one isn't. That is the gap SoniClear works to close, so that no hearing goes unrecorded while courts keep building their reporter workforce.

For more than 20 years, SoniClear software has helped digital court reporters capture the record reliably. A digital court reporter is a trained professional who runs the courtroom recording and produces the official transcript. Today we pair our technology with training through our partnership with the Institute for Digital Court Reporting (IDCR).

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I record my own hearing on my phone?

Only if the judge allows it, and even then it can serve only as your personal notes. It does not count as an official record for an appeal.

Who can ask the court to record a hearing?

Anyone who cannot reasonably afford a private court reporter. You do not need a fee waiver or a formal application.

Does the ruling apply outside Los Angeles, Santa Clara, Contra Costa, and San Diego?

The court's order names those four courts. The duty it describes, however, rests on a power every California trial court has, and courts statewide are now working out how to respond.

Does this replace court reporters?

No. If an official court reporter is available, the reporter makes the record. Recording is for hearings where no reporter is available.

Planning Your Court's Response?

When a court reporter is available, they belong in the courtroom. When one isn't, every person in court still deserves a record they can rely on. If your court is planning its response to this ruling, I'd welcome the conversation. Reach me at Helene@soniclear.com or 626.768.0126 to schedule a demo, or visit soniclear.com.

Researched and drafted with AI assistance; reviewed, fact checked, and edited by Helene Vinson.

Sources